American ww1 uniform vs british reddit I've also worn my American Civil War Union impression and people really liked it, got stopped for pictures alot and the local national guard that had a recruiting thing at the event posted a picture of them with me on their facebook page They were organized along British lines, used British equipment, trained the same way as British soldiers, operated with largely British doctrine (though tbf there were some interesting things going on with the Australians towards the end of the war that were pretty unique to them), relied heavily on British artillery, administrative, and A couple years ago I read a book about a British infantry regiment’s experiences during the American Revolution. a quick look at ceremonial soliders in a number of European and South American countries also shows Victorian era Prussian style uniforms, what happened to freeze ceremonial dress uniforms in this era The British, for example, had uniforms from the time of the Boer War that very much resembled their World War 1 uniforms, at least compared to the colorful French ones. The Battlefield 1 subreddit. Sadly, I’m not aware of any other action games in the Napleonic war to WW1 era that also has lances. Jul 10, 2013 · I have seen photos (and original uniforms) of US troops in British made US uniforms. A Navy Lieutenant is O-3, and Lieutenant Junior Grade is O-2; Army Lieutenant 2nd Class is O-1, and First Class is O-2. Really wish decent repros existed. There is a small color difference, but not much. The British Army entered WW1 with uniforms designed for traditional warfare but soon adapted them for trench warfare. However, that is an enlisted uniform, with enlisted collar discs and a WW1 era specialist rank that was somewhat equivalent to PFC. A subreddit for talking about the collecting of gas masks, PPE, and other related equipment. ) Ive tried sites like Amazon, but every seller I found felt sketchy. I need help finding any good websites to purchase WW1 American doughboy uniforms, any help would be appreciated. As the Canadian Armed Forces continues to undue the ceremonial/uniform disaster of amalgamation, this new service dress is a reflection of a return to traditional Canadian army/militia uniforms. Dole's USMC officer's uniform. people seem to like it for the most part, some folks might think its WW2 though and get a bit upset. Feb 14, 2011 · You may have to squint real hard to tell the difference between a Doughboy and “Tommy Atkins” in a WW1 photo. Extemporized khaki was widespread during the Indian Mutiny of 1857-59 and proper khaki and drab uniforms were issued to some elements for the Second Opium War and the majority of troops for the Abyssinian Campaign. There are a lot of photos and whatnot of Russian troops wearing white during the 19 Welcome to the home of Battlefield V! Your place for discussion, help, news, reviews, questions, screenshots, videos, gifs, and anything else BFV related! 1/2. Excellent question! Modification of uniforms was one of the facets of British colonial warfare- particularly in the first half of the 19th century. The British Army began to make serious efforts at campaign uniforms during the mid-19thC. 45 Holster, a WW1 British Rain Cape, and a WW1 US Army Canteen Cup? And that pretty much wraps it all up for the Americans! Well I like Sheamus (or whatever his name was, haven't played in a long time, the Irish guy with the green hat) apart from his cringey personality, he had the only somewhat accurate British uniform for a long time, although I would never spend that much money on a skin. I'm not exactly sure why I started collecting them. We are a subreddit for historical reenactment Its all about reenactors who… Now, officers in the WWI-era British Army still tended to be from the upper classes (at least if we're talking about the pre-war Regular Army or senior officers throughout the war; by 1916 a significant proportion of junior officers were from the middle and even working classes due to the unprecedented expansion in the size of the Army), but Depends what you mean by Camouflage, it's a really broad term. By the time WWI rolled around, most armies had standardized on one color per general uniform type; there was some variation in color tabs, piping, insignia, and so on, but overall the goal was to make the whole force's uniforms look more, uh, uniform. The British and French weren't just concerned about winning the war, but winning the post-war world that they wanted. Make sure to follow the rules and enjoy your time here! I draw the line for uniforms vs equipment otherwise. Both Jarema and BAXIII can have very long wait times and there is suspicion that BAXIII charges more for American customers. Petty Officers in the Navy (E-4 through E-6) wear a spread eagle as part of their uniform. WW1, Spanish-American War and American Civil War. When the soldiers get liberty (time off) in, say, Paris or Cairo, they wear their wrinkled service uniform. Any help would be greatly appreciated! In real life, the practice of every regiment having its own distinctive uniform largely stopped in the 19th century. The British had 160,000, the French 1,200,000 and the Russians 1,400,000. We also know from some cabinet discussions that the British were worried about their new ally becoming too powerful in the post-war order. World War One British Uniform. mort338888 Fairly sure that some ww1 uniforms had shirt and tie as well. Above that is Mundury Jarema (excellent) in Poland and BAXIII in Germany. A subreddit for posting and discussion of ForgottenWeapons, InRange TV videos and the subject… No idea what’s going on in this thread rn, but to answer your question, I bought most of my WW1 British stuff from What Price Glory. Uniforms for pre-Korean war should not be worn for reenactment and should be only for display. The US started issuing khaki to some units during the Spanish American War but khaki wouldn't replace blue untill around 1902 ish. Similarly, P37 webbing had largely replaced the P08 set (personally, I prefer P08, but that's neither here nor there). A lot of clothes in the pics (mind you these were mass produced one size fits all uniforms) today would be sold as overpriced stylist design crap. Also want to try an elaborate scene of Joe Clum and the native american police force. Similar to the Guard units, the government would pull more funds for the uniforms of the navy or artillery than the regular infantry. Many US soldiers even carried British rifles or US Enfields that looked like British rifles. Liberalism is the ideology of capitalism, free markets, representative democracy, legal rights and state monopoly on violence. U. In order: American Revolutionary War soldier, British Revolutionary War soldier, Union Civil War soldier, American WW1 Soldier, American WW2 Soldier, German WW2 Officer, WW2/Cold War Soviet Officer General, American Vietnam Soldier, Modern American Soldier, Ukraine War (Ukrainian) Soldier Mar 29, 2024 · Hauk111 on DeviantArt https://www. When it comes to my WW1 uniforms, my favorite is probably 2nd Lt. For example the rifles. It may work much better if you switch the officer’s type hat for a helmet. Uniforms were different; P37 battledress had replaced the P02 service dress uniform. US Army divisions, regiments, battalions, etc), while the French and British had tried to convince the US to basically provide basically little packets of Americans to bring French and British units up to strength. The Early War British Uniform (1914-1915) Jul 15, 2022 · Standardised uniforms were used to instil discipline and esprit de corps on the battlefield, with new technology enabling advances in mass production, wear, comfort and suitability of the outfits to a variety of climates. Smokeless powder was invented in the late 1800's (edit: 1884 - but it wasn't in universal use for years afterwards) and I believe more than a few people therefore assume correlation with the widespread use of drab uniform in WWI, but there were changes to drab before that invention, and more significant changes to warfare than just smokeless Locked due to reddit protests, until the 14. g. For the various bits of gear that go along with the uniform (SBR, paybook, ID tags), I went with Soldier of Fortune. Having the rank insignia on the collar is the proper regulation method but over the course of the Pacific War, units also started to just use a single rank insignia on a cotton or wool tab that is attached to the shirt via button or pin. Collar and pockets biggest difference. Which the Marines often took to with scissors, needle, and thread, swapping their P12 uniform buttons over and such. com/hauk111/art/WW1-American-Soldier-Overcoat-1036496805 Hauk111 https://www. The Medical Response to the Trench Diseases in World War One. i really hope they'll update the german uniform models because this is very inaccurate, and as someone who's very into the subject of german uniforms from ww2 it's annoying to see they don't put the effort in. The Russians adopted brown to replace the green 1880s uniform around 1907 because of lessons learnt from the British experience in the 2nd Boer War. VII Respirator Bag, US M1907/10 Ammo Belt, a Pattern 1908 Small Pack, a US Model 1917 Bolo Knife holster, US Cavalry . The turn of the century marked a uniform change for the Army. true. Interestingly enough, the British army lost the royal distinction as a whole after the Cromwell wars, while the Navy and Artillery kept it. The Evolution of British WW1 Uniforms. The Roosevelt administration essentially having the task of inventing a modern American military wanted a uniform that was unlike a military uniform and more akin to a workmans uniform Welcome to the home of Battlefield V! Your place for discussion, help, news, reviews, questions, screenshots, videos, gifs, and anything else BFV related! Sounds like fuddlore-level crap. A Navy Captain is O-6; Army Captains are O-3. Images are drawn from Laurent Mirouze, World War I Infantry in Colour (Crowood Press, 1999): French Infantryman August 1914--the obsolete cut and color of the uniform had been long notedd, and between 1903 and 1914 various "drab, gray-blue, beige-blue, reseda-green" outfits had been proffered and prototyped, without adoption. There were repair and replacement Bekleidungsamts for just such purposes, and reissue markings stamped in the uniforms to quantify that. The US civil war was “when new tech meets old tactics” one reason why it was such a bloody conflict. Basically, the lesson they took from 1870 (when they had focused on defense and gotten encircled for their trouble) was that clearly they needed to get back to the aggression of Napoleonic tactics, and charge in dense columns (to keep up momentum/elan) under cover of artillery (which mostly didn't even materialize due to 118K subscribers in the ForgottenWeapons community. The issue with WW1 and 2 British uniforms isnt aesthetics but material, most of the uniforms of the British Empire were made of a very thick and coarse wool that was incredibly uncomfortable and itchy by modern standards, due to an archaic belief that the more you sweated the cooler you would eventually get. High-ranking officers may also have their dress uniforms, but mostly wear service uniforms, as evidenced by most pictures of WWII generals; civilians often mistake these service uniforms for dress uniforms. It’s also worth mentioning that the World War 1 first person shooter Battlefield 1 had added cavalry lances as an optional replacement for the cavalry sabre in one of the content expansions. The uniform issued to an infantryman during the period from 1815 consisted of either a swallow-tailed coat or a short round jacket with dark grey trousers, topped with a heavy, broad-topped shako (used until 1842 It varied based on the unit's preference. This is a great question! There is of course a tight relationship between the early United States and the French, thanks to French support during the War for Independence, but the French Revolution introduced some complexities to that relationship, and the United States fought a truncated war, the Quasi-War, against France in 1798, and duri 813 votes, 129 comments. So it wasn't even "we don't want to have those losses" as it was "there's no point in fighting". Feb 21, 2025 · This guide will explore the history, evolution, and key components of British military uniforms during World War I. It includes a large portion of the present day political spectrum, from the centre-left social democrats to the far-right conservatives and American libertarians. Mar 1, 2025 · This guide explores the primary WW1 uniform types, including the distinctive uniforms of British, French, and US soldiers. The P12 uniforms wore out and it was way easier to give them the Army uniforms as replacements. 246K subscribers in the battlefield_one community. S. The main weight was with British Third and Fourth Armies, and these largely comprised of British divisions, with the ANZAC Corps operating frequently with the Fourth. I've always been into military stuff for as long as I could remember. . However, for some equipment there is no reproduction option (like WWI reenactment, you have to use original weapons) and so there are exceptions for specific items that are not reproduced (yet). Lots of mixed info in this thread. The M1910 service uniform, issued for work and field use, was the service's first uniform that was solely one color. At the onset of World War 1 in 1914, the British Army wore the 1902 Pattern Service Dress, a practical departure from the bright red uniforms of the 19th century. Even with all the reservists, the British army in particular was not well placed (700,000 against 3,800,000 on the German side). Very generally: It was a rough start. This subreddit is for the ephemeral TV programs of the pre-VCR era -- the stuff no one ever expected to see again: newscasts, local kiddie shows and horror movie hosts, live TV dramas, game shows, soap operas, teen dance parties That’s a really nice uniform, and 7th ID is a great unit. We wore the British “Brodie” style helmet and the US tunics were patterned after the British uniform. The other ones are garbage. Do not go to Epic or Military Harbor for WWI uniforms Yeah actually, since I'm on a WW1 streak right now, I plan to post a character I made about a year ago inspired the Battlefield 1 interpretation of the Harlem Hellfighters. Compare American Navy and Coast Guard rank and recognition to the other branches. Atenstaedt, Robert. It was definitely more a logistics thing. Tunic was wartime made in Paris, explaining the lighter Something I learned the other day was the American uniform in WW2 was in part a product of the new deal. 15K subscribers in the reenactors community. World War I. The US military had insisted on fighting as "national" units (i. Aside from Amiens and Canal du Nord, the Canadian Corps fought as part of British 1st Army, and thus was not at the spearhead of the BEF. His equipment is an British MK. Cambridge Scholars The only uniform i've found that was accurate for the germans are the ones for the pilots, they actually include the insignia too. Meaning it would be easier for DICE to scratch the paint off of the british uniforms, dye them a tad bit different, put the US eagle and such and call it a day. That's because the Brits in South Africa were some of the first Europeans to see what facing modern weaponry and guerilla tactics required from uniforms. Army Infantry uniform. e. I don't use it at events at all but the repros of WWI US officer uniforms are so lackluster that I thought it would be cool to showcase what it should look like. 1. 165 votes, 20 comments. People loved the Gas mask. I’m looking to purchase a uniform just like the one pictured, webbing and all (rifle optional. comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment Just to check, is he a British Sikh serving in the army or is he a Sikh from overseas serving as part of the British army? I think if he was British by nationality he would have worn the British regimentals according to his rank, as I'm unsure whether the British forces would've accommodated for religious and cultural dress in uniform, except in specialist regiments where evrybody was part of Entirely original uniform, only gloves and boots are repro (boots based off a 1910 model). The British wore khaki uniforms throughout World War One. William A. The colours used are the same colours found on Canadian service dress uniforms in the 1920s and most of the 1930s. The fact that he also participates in every major action in WW1 is also suspicious. Khaki patterned uniforms of the British Army being used in the in the second Boer War so as to not stand out as much vs the traditional red coat. deviantart. The life expectancy of the uniform in the field was roughly 6 months, and logistically having new uniforms issued constantly was not plausible. 86 votes, 15 comments. If you consider mono-coloured uniforms (or rather mono-coloured articles of clothing that make up the uniform) as camouflage, then it already existed long before WW1 (e. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. This is not a prepping subreddit. This makes the insistence on an independent American presence much more justifiable. By the time of the us civil war modern rifled muskets were pretty accurate, but the tactics with whom the battles were fought were designed for pretty inaccurate smoothbore muskets. Double stitching increased longevity, and removable buttons made laundering more practical and efficient. Forced marches in those wool uniforms during the summer in South Carolina sounded absolutely miserable. In the earliest efforts to match uniforms with climate conditions and modern technologies, the army introduced khaki in the Cuban invasion of 1898 (Spanish American War). A number of officers from the French army were part of the Vichy French government. That all I can gather from the image as it’s quite hard to research specific uniforms from that long ago (or at least I find it so). Supposedly his unit fought in the first four battles at the Isonzo (I'm pretty sure no German unit fought in Italy at that time because Italy and Germany had not declared war against each other), while at the same time invading Serbia with the Bulgarians The French military in the first few months of WW1 was something else. Battlefield 1 is developed by DICE and… After WW1 French society kinda fell apart, it was heading towards a fascist vs communist Civil War before WW2 started. For pre-1980 or so TV shows -- but not the usual Lucy or *Gunsmoke* reruns. One thing that struck me seeing the Queens funeral on TV was that so many of the British dress uniforms belong in the late 19th century or earlier, similar with other commonwealth countries. The Germans were notoriously efficient when it came to recycling. Schusters is the cheapest option that requires no alterations. The rest of the stuff I sourced from Ebay. From my understanding, the US uniforms were almost identical to their British counterparts. Looks a lot like a British Royal Navy uniform, potentially some sort of “social” or “off duty” uniform, from the late 1800s/early 1900s, though he’s notably missing his cap. The French army straight up didn't want to fight. The British navy had blue, likewise with the artillery. My father was in the army so I guess that's what really sparked it. com/hauk111/art/WW1-American-Soldier The British followed a similar path, with the introduction of battledress uniform which similarly replaced the puttees with a gaiter, and began to be issued in 1938 (not entirely phased out by the war, particularly in the colonial forces). shaqwp athys eoass fmd snzhwa zttjtbxb zqvz lcxpn mlsydhm uhjjhk