Did jesus forgive judas reddit Did Jesus forgive Judas? No. Now that we have seen examples of jesus forgiving those who 1. Additionally, it's an important note to realize that the motive behind Judas' betrayal was less in proportion to what Peter did—which Jesus knew he would do. But when they denied him, Judas still did not return to Jesus for forgiveness. However God chose this way for two reasons, to show us the nature of His love, and so that true worship and sacrifice could be offered to the Father through the Passion and the Eucharist Yes we do. At the end of season two, this was reversed. Either way, Judas was from the south, the land dominated by the Israelite tribes who returned from Assyria 75 years earlier, and most likely descended from Edomite conver It seems to me that the statement Jesus made there would include Judas, since he was part of the scheme of the cross. Yes, I believe Jesus forgave Judas. And that same night, Peter denied Christ. He did wrong, but Jesus gave him several opportunities to repent. These are examples of jesus’ unconditional love and mercy for us. Jesus’ crucifixion is necessary, so if not Judas, than someone else would be needed to fulfill the prophecy. He did not forgive…. They both prayed constantly for the accusers of Jesus throughout the Passion. Jesus literally told Judas it would have been better had he never been born. Will lied to Hannibal and betrayed him, becoming Judas. Infinity is up to the person in question. 35 And the people stood beholding. But Hannibal doesn't handle the betrayal as Jesus did. Posted by u/[Deleted Account] - 3 votes and 12 comments Sep 22, 2024 · I am well aware that I'm risking all of my karma for this but hear me out. I’ve always heard love the sinner not the sin. Sorry. Jesus does not share a conscious mind with the Father, and prays to him on multiple occasions. Did Jesus forgive, in his last words, those who persecuted him and crucified him? Yes. But better for Judas himself. Judas did not forgive himself, or accept the forgiveness of Christ. Judas, rather than turn back, killed himself. Judas is probably the hardest person for Jesus to forgive in the world, but if He could forgive Judas, then surely He could forgive anyone else. In John 13:18, Jesus makes reference to Psalm 41:9 to talk about Judas Iscariot. Judas was attempting to force Jesus to use His powers to fight & take over the Roman power. In knowing that, it was preordained. 3. ) So it isn't that far fetched to think the same occurred So did Judas. Peter repented, Judas did not. If it wasn’t for the endless love of the Trinity I would have never have been able to forgive the sex abuse and rape I endured for 17 years. Forgiveness does not always equal salvation, though salvation obviously requires it. And they parted his raiment, and cast lots. When someone says "If Christianity is real, why did {insert pastor's name here} do {insert sin here}? See hypocrites!" we can point to examples of where people who knew Jesus directly did some pretty bad stuff. In order for Jesus to fulfill his destiny he needed to die for Dec 5, 2005 · Did Jesus forgive Judas? Yes, at least up to an age of accountability as God gives all babies and children who are born in sin that grace period of forgiveness. And yet Jesus would have restored him. Remember what Jesus said about doing the Devil's desires? John 8:44 Jesus had seen the Devil possess Judas. When Judas had eaten the bread, Satan entered into him. Jesus’ love is unending and unquenchable, and Jesus said that blasphemes against the son of man would be forgiven. We also know the Devil told Jesus to kill himself. Iscariot means Man from Karioth; it was either an Edomite town in the far south, or a Moabite town across the Jordan River. Judas did not betray Jesus as an act of evil. Through the Gospels it's implied that Judas was destined to betray Jesus, but the gospels are written after it happened. The false repentance of Judas was like that of Esau. The gospels place Judas in the position of one that was prophecied in the Old Testament to betray Jesus. Our Lady and Jesus prayed for Judas right until the end but ultimately there was no hope, he was too far gone. They clearly blasphemed the Holy Spirit when they witnessed an irrefutable miracle and assigned them to the devil. Yet he didn’t bother turning to Jesus for forgiveness. Judas tried to confess to the priests (Matt. Judas was as necessary as Jesus. Jesus was speaking to a wealthy man who desired salvation, and knew that his weakness was his wealth. Judas was even in the room where they judged Jesus, and he told the leaders he regressed selling him out. Judas Iscariot betrayed Jesus Christ and later acknowledged that he had spilled innocent blood and returned the Silver, Judas appeared to have Judas Iscariot (if Jesus was in-fact God in flesh) is the most evil man who has ever lived. Due to that, I think it is very possible that Jesus did forgive Judas, there's no question in my mind Jesus did. And really, we all betray Jesus when we sin, I think Satans real trick is to convince us we don't deserve grace from God. Unfortunately it seems even with direct intervention there is no hope for some people, that should be a stark warning for us all. The Jewish authorities did not want to kill Jesus on their own because if they did then that meant that they defied Roman authority. Meier agrees, noting that although we know very little about Judas, the scholarly consensus says that “Jesus chose him as one of the Twelve, and he handed over Jesus to the Jerusalem authorities, thus precipitating Jesus's execution. Dipping and sharing bread was a token of friendship in their culture. God wasn't the one who tempted Judas. Also God didn’t create Judas to end up in hell but because if his actions he ended up there. The scene where L is cleaning Light's feet, it's a reference to the bible when Jesus cleans Judas's feet, the point of that scene in the bible is that it's about forgiving your enemies. Does this mean that L forgave Light? I know they didn't consider each other friends but they did enjoy playing their little game. " To deliver Jesus, Judas had to fulfill his obligation under the diabolical covenant he made to deliver him. Felt remorse. Luke even goes so far as to have Jesus forgive his executioners from the cross. (Sure, he didn't get Jesus killed, but he DID deny Jesus after Jesus said he would, and it didn't register to him until after it was done. Luke 23:34 Then said Jesus, Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do. Judas did not betray Jesus as an act of evil, it was a trap just like with Adam and Eve. You do need to ask for forgiveness and believe what you did was a sin and want forgiveness. Judas did not betray Jesus - Paul and Mark do not say such a thing. The implication is that he didn’t forgive the people responsible for his death who did know what they were doing. We are no different when looking at both actions' baselines God sent Jesus so that all sins would be forgiven. This interpretation challenges the notion of Judas as a mere pawn of Satan and prompts us to reconsider his actions in a more compassionate light. Judas felt so horrible for what he did that he killed himself. 24 votes, 26 comments. S. Mark had every motivation, even a need, to shift the blame for the crucifixion away from the Romans and onto Jewish authorities. Jesus even knew about Judas, as He was able to see through men’s hearts. All he had to do was ask God for forgiveness and truly turn his life around and continue Jesus's work like the other apostles did, but he decided to commit suicide. Jesus called him "a devil" as well, saying it would have been better for Judas if he'd never been born. What would have happened if Judas had instead turned back to the all-forgiving Jesus? Jesus even went into the grave to get Adam Moses David Abraham etc who all committed serious crimes like disobedience, murder, adultery and setting someone’s husband up to die to weasel his way out of punishment (David specifically) but he said F Judas and brought them up. Judas was never “saved,” but for a time he was a follower of Yes, he could have—and would have—if he had repented of his sin and asked for forgiveness from Jesus as did Peter. God knows. Jesus says “It would have been better for him if he was never created. Unlike the other disciples that called Jesus “Lord,” Judas never used this title for Jesus and instead called him “Rabbi,” which acknowledged Jesus as nothing more than a teacher. Acts 1:15 seems to suggest Judas is turned over to himself, that he might go to his own place (which is the fate of those in hell). Even after his dreadful deed, Judas could have fallen on his knees to beg God’s forgiveness. There was a Book of Judas floating around purportedly written by Judas and he claimed he and Jesus preplanned the whole thing and that Jesus told him it was a great honor and responsibility. Additionally, Paul writes "that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures" (1 Corinthians 15:3) which is corroborated by the Gospels to include the betrayal of Jesus Christ by Judas Iscariot. (Qualified answer, but it sure doesn’t sound good for Judas if Jesus said ‘twould be better if he had never been born) Does Jesus heal? Yes. Not better for the world, because Jesus needed to die on the cross. they have the resources, armed resource, network to get Jesus--- with or w/o Judas, Salvation has to happen through the Jesus's sacrifice. Feb 24, 2021 · The Bible says, “But whoever blasphemes against the Holy Spirit never has forgiveness, but is guilty of an eternal sin” (Mark 3:29). The only documented discussion between Judas and Jesus involves Jesus rebuking Judas after his greedy remark to Mary in John 12:1-8, Judas denying the betrayal and the actual betrayal. If Judas would have knelt at the cross, and asked Jesus to forgive him, would Jesus say no? Of course not, in fact, Christ would forgive Judas, just as along with us all: Father forgive them, for they know not what they do . Skip to main content. Then when Jesus returned (and forgave Peter), Judas had already committed suicide so wasn’t here. There was no way Judas would not betray Jesus, as he was chosen as a disciple because of his traitorous character. So he put the man to the test, and the man failed miserably. Again, forgiveness without salvation is meaningless. Lewis portrays the betrayer (Edmond) in The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. Satan likely told Judas it was for the greater good, which it was, but when he did it, God damned him. Regardless of Jesus warning Judas that Jesus would be betrayed, Judas still betrayed him. This passage can only make sense if it is saying Judas is in hell. Then Jesus told him, “Hurry and do what you’re going to do. Tried to undo his evil works. Do not confess and 2. Jun 2, 2020 · Here is the bottom line: The sin of Judas was great. The question is why doing sacrifices at all, god is all powerful why can't he just forgive and be merciful as he is supposed to be instead of sacrificing himself (which wasn't a sacrifice because jesus resurrected after 3 days, a sacrifice is giving up something for a greater good and jesus or god didn't lose anything because he came back). Judas served a purpose in God’s plan of redemption for humanity. In summary, Jesus may have chosen to forgive Peter for various reasons - among them an identifiable relationship between Peter's sin and possible repentance - which could explain why He showed mercy whereas He withheld his personal favor from Judas Iscariot who showed no sign of having received conviction or humility whatsoever towards correcting his wrong doing against God and/or humanity at I get that, but it's about the basics of the action, not just how we do it. When you read his Gospel you see he imbues every story with deep theological meaning. Scripture tells us there are vessels that are made for destruction. nnh vqtzmu ynmd hygjw kip shgef khlo fdvhhvcc eqfbaq ncgodli hpzrid qsdbo uwfya otgbas zvhh